Sunderland vs Everton prediction, H2H and probable lineups, November 3, 2025

By Author On Nov 3, 2025

Sunderland are gearing up to welcome Everton to the Stadium of Light this Monday night, and honestly, this one could be more interesting than it looks on paper. The Black Cats have been putting up some brave performances lately, while Everton are still trying to find their rhythm after an up-and-down start to the season.

Both sides need points — Sunderland to move clear of the bottom half and Everton to climb toward mid-table safety. So expect a tight, nervy encounter with plenty of energy and emotion.

Form Guide

Sunderland: W-L-D-L-W
Sunderland have been unpredictable but improving. Their last home win showed a lot of fighting spirit, especially in attack. The defense, though, still looks shaky and has leaked goals at bad times.
Everton: D-L-W-W-L
Everton’s form is all over the place too. They’ve shown flashes of quality, but consistency remains the issue. Their away record isn’t terrible, but they’ve struggled to kill off games when leading.

This could honestly go either way depending on who settles faster on the night.

Head-to-Head (H2H)

Everton have had the upper hand in recent meetings, winning most of their past five games against Sunderland. But the Black Cats did manage to grab a point the last time they played at home, showing they can frustrate the Toffees if they get their tactics right.

Last 5 meetings:
Everton wins – 3 | Sunderland wins – 1 | Draws – 1

Don’t be surprised if we see another close one this time.

Team News

Sunderland:
A few injuries are still haunting them. Their top striker remains a doubt after picking up a knock, and the midfield might see some rotation. The manager is expected to stick with a back four after it worked well last week.

Everton:
Everton have some fitness worries too. Their captain could return, which would be a massive boost for the defense. The attacking trio looks settled, but they’ll need to be more clinical in front of goal.

Probable Lineups

Sunderland (4-2-3-1):
Goalkeeper – Patterson
Defenders – Hume, Ballard, O’Nien, Cirkin
Midfielders – Neil, Ekwah
Attackers – Roberts, Pritchard, Clarke
Striker – Hemir

Players to Watch

Jack Clarke (Sunderland): His pace and creativity down the left could be a real headache for Everton’s full-backs.
Dominic Calvert-Lewin (Everton): When he’s fit and confident, he can bully defenders and find the net out of nowhere.

Both of these guys could decide the game on their day.

Prediction

This feels like one of those scrappy Monday night matches where neither team fully dominates. Sunderland will try to ride the home support, but Everton have enough experience to nick a result.

Predicted Score: Sunderland 1–1 Everton

Betting Tips

Both Teams to Score (BTTS): ✅ Looks good – both sides leak goals.
Over 2.5 Goals: ❌ Risky – might be too cagey early on.
Draw: ✅ Decent value considering both teams’ form.

If you like a safe flutter, “BTTS + Draw” could be your best shout.

Wrap-Up

It’s shaping up to be a tense, hard-fought battle under the lights at the Stadium of Light. Sunderland’s fight meets Everton’s resilience — not exactly glamorous, but full of grit. Expect moments of chaos, a few late chances, and maybe some drama right at the end.

Whatever happens, both managers will just want to leave with no regrets (and probably a clean sheet, if that’s even possible).