Alexander Isak ‘lost’ trust in Newcastle after broken promises

By Author On Aug 20, 2025

Alexander Isak, Newcastle United’s prolific striker, has publicly announced that he has “lost trust” in the club due to “broken promises,” marking a dramatic turning point in his relationship with Newcastle. This follows a summer filled with transfer speculation, a rejected £110 million bid from Liverpool, and Isak’s absence from team activities and significant club events. Here’s an in-depth exploration of what happened, why it matters, and what it means going forward for both Isak and Newcastle.

TL;DR

Alexander Isak says Newcastle broke promises about his future, eroding trust and prompting him to push for a transfer.
Newcastle rejected a £110 million Liverpool offer and denies any commitment to let Isak leave this summer.
Isak has opted out of team events and trained separately, signaling he does not intend to return to play for Newcastle.
Both parties remain at an impasse, with Newcastle emphasizing their “family feel” and Isak seeking change for his career’s best interest.

Alexander Isak’s Breaking Point: Why Trust Was Lost at Newcastle

Isak, who joined Newcastle in 2022 from Real Sociedad, swiftly became a key figure for the club. Last season, he scored 27 goals in all competitions, including a decisive goal in Newcastle’s Carabao Cup final victory over Liverpool—a historic trophy for the club after 70 years. Despite this success, the summer of 2025 saw his relationship with Newcastle sour publicly.

In a heartfelt social media post, Isak revealed that promises made to him—likely regarding his future at the club and potential transfers—were broken. His exact words were:

“I’ve remained silent for a long time while others have spoken. That silence has allowed people to push their own version of events, even though they know it doesn’t reflect what was really said and agreed behind closed doors. The reality is that promises were made and the club has known my position for a long time. When promises are broken and trust is lost, the relationship can’t continue. That’s where things are for me right now.”

He further expressed gratitude to his teammates and Newcastle staff but clarified why he chose not to attend the PFA awards ceremony—despite being named in the Premier League Team of the Season—due to the ongoing situation making it “not feel right.”

Isak’s statement strongly indicates a belief that an understanding or commitment was reached with club officials, particularly regarding his potential departure to a top club, but Newcastle ultimately did not honor those expectations.

What Newcastle Says: No Promises Made, Club Loyalty Emphasized

Newcastle United swiftly responded with an official club statement, refuting Isak’s claims of broken promises. The club emphasized:

No commitment from any official allowing Isak to leave during the summer transfer window was made.
The club is under contract with Isak, and conditions for his sale have not been met.
While they understand player wishes and listen to their views, decisions are made prioritizing the club, team, and supporters.
Newcastle stressed their pride in club traditions and the family atmosphere, assuring Isak he remains part of that family and will be welcomed back when ready.

Newcastle coach Eddie Howe described the situation as “unhealthy” and noted it had affected squad morale. Howe also mentioned the door is still open for Isak’s reintegration if the player wishes, but the relationship and atmosphere have clearly been strained.

The Transfer Drama: Liverpool’s £110 Million Bid and Isak’s Career Choices

Liverpool’s reported £110 million bid for Isak was rejected by Newcastle, who consider him not for sale. Despite this, Isak’s stance is firm: he has no intention of playing for Newcastle again if his preferred move does not materialize. Isak has trained apart from the squad, skipped the pre-season Asian tour, and missed the Premier League opener against Aston Villa.

What This Means for Fans and Followers of Premier League Football

For Newcastle fans, this saga is both a disappointment and a complex dilemma. On one hand, Isak’s contributions to recent successes are undeniable; on the other, the club’s desire to hold on to their star clashes with the player’s career ambitions.

For followers of the Premier League transfer market, this story underscores the challenges clubs face balancing contractual control with players’ personal ambitions and market realities. It also highlights the human element behind transfers—trust, broken promises, and relationships that cannot simply be reduced to contracts.

Looking Ahead: What Could Happen Next?

Isak could potentially remain at Newcastle but face a challenging path reintegrating given his current reluctance.
Additional bids from Liverpool or other top clubs could emerge, although Newcastle’s firm stance remains.
Newcastle could pursue new striker targets if Isak departs, signaling a squad reshuffle.
The situation will continue to dominate headlines and impact Newcastle’s Premier League campaign.

Alexander Isak’s Impact at Newcastle: A Career Snapshot

Goals: 27 in the 2024-25 season across all competitions.
Achievements: Key player in Newcastle’s Carabao Cup win, their first major domestic trophy in 70 years.
Recognition: Premier League Team of the Season 2024-25.
Current status: Training separately and absent from team events due to transfer disputes.

FAQ: People Also Ask About Alexander Isak and Newcastle

Why has Alexander Isak lost trust in Newcastle?

Isak publicly stated that promises were made by the club regarding his future, which were not fulfilled. This breach of trust has led him to conclude the relationship with Newcastle cannot continue.

What was Newcastle’s response to Isak’s accusations?

Newcastle denied making any commitments that Isak could leave during the summer and emphasized their contractual rights while affirming Isak remains part of their family.

Is Alexander Isak leaving Newcastle this summer?

The situation remains unresolved. Liverpool’s bid was rejected and Newcastle insists Isak is not for sale. Isak has made clear his desire to move, but no transfer has yet been agreed.

How has the situation affected Newcastle’s team?

Coach Eddie Howe described the situation as unhealthy and noted it impacted squad morale. Isak’s absence has been felt during preseason and the early Premier League matches.