Josh Sargent faces criticism as Norwich City standoff intensifies amid MLS transfer push
Josh Sargent’s future at Norwich City has taken a dramatic turn, with the USMNT striker facing criticism after effectively removing himself from selection as he seeks a move away from Carrow Road, with a switch to MLS now gathering momentum.
The 25 year old has been one of the Championship’s standout forwards, scoring 31 goals across the last two seasons, but remains under contract until 2028 and has yet to secure a move despite interest from higher-profile clubs.
That impasse has led to a growing standoff. Sargent has stepped away from matchday contention, with Toronto FC reported to have lodged an offer that would take him back to North America in a World Cup year.
Former USMNT goalkeeper Brad Friedel has questioned the striker’s approach, making clear that while ambition is understandable, the method matters. Friedel described Sargent as a respected figure but suggested his current stance crosses an important professional line.
The situation carries wider significance for Norwich. Sargent has been viewed as the most complete forward in the Championship, a relentless runner with improved finishing, and his goals have been central to the club’s promotion ambitions. With the season finely balanced, any prolonged absence changes the dynamic both on and off the pitch.
At Carrow Road, the mood has shifted from admiration to frustration. Norwich have taken a firm position, insisting that any departure must be on their terms, while supporters remain caught between understanding a player’s career goals and expecting full commitment on matchdays.
The controversy mirrors recent high-profile disputes elsewhere. Friedel pointed to the example of Alexander Isak, who forced his way out of Newcastle before completing a major move, arguing that refusing to play places unnecessary strain on teammates, staff, and fans.
When matches have unfolded without Sargent, Norwich have lacked their usual focal point. His pressing from the front, link-up play, and penalty-box instincts have often set the tempo early, particularly in tight Championship fixtures where margins are slim.
There have been no defining goals in this saga yet, but the absence itself has become the key moment, with Toronto’s bid acting as the trigger and Norwich’s resistance shaping the narrative.
As the season progresses, attention now turns to whether compromise can be reached. MLS offers Sargent security, familiarity, and a central role ahead of the World Cup, while staying in England keeps him in a competitive European environment.
For now, the striker’s four-and-a-half-year spell in English football appears to be nearing its conclusion. With 56 goals in 156 appearances, Sargent leaves a strong record behind, but how this chapter ends may influence how he is remembered at Norwich as much as the goals he scored.