Premier League clubs have voted 18-2 to cover their board members’ legal costs if Manchester City’s sponsors sue them. The vote took place at a shareholders’ meeting in London on Thursday 19 November. It was, in fact, the first meeting of the clubs since the September verdict.
The Premier League clubs vote was about legal protection, not about City’s punishment. It does not decide what sanction City will face. It does not change the guilty verdict. It simply means the league’s directors will have their legal costs covered if City’s sponsors, Etihad Airways and Etisalat, carry out their threat to sue them.
Both sponsors have also said they are considering legal action against the Premier League. They were not named in the independent commission’s verdict, but they say the findings have damaged them. The clubs have now moved to protect the five people the sponsors might sue. Only Manchester City and Nottingham Forest voted against the plan, but their reasons were very different.
One point must be made plainly. Some headlines have presented this as a vote on City’s punishment. It was not. The punishment is still undecided, and the league has set no date for it. The vote was about who pays the lawyers if the sponsors sue. That is a different question, and it matters for a different reason.
Last updated: November 2026
What the Premier League Clubs Vote Decided
The Premier League clubs vote took place at a meeting in central London on Thursday morning. The Premier League clubs vote followed the sponsors’ threats to take legal action. The item on the agenda was a change to the league’s rules on legal indemnity for its directors.
Under the league’s current rules, the league covers a director who wins a legal case brought by a third party. They are not covered if they lose. The clubs voted to change that. The five board members will now have their legal costs covered even if a case goes against them. The change passed by 18 votes to two. The change needed a two-thirds majority, 14 clubs.
The five board members are Alison Brittain, the chair, and Richard Masters, the chief executive. The other three are non-executive directors: Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder. If Etihad or Etisalat sue any of them individually, the league will pay their legal costs. The vote means the protection is now in place before anyone files a case.
| Board member | Role |
|---|---|
| Alison Brittain | Chair |
| Richard Masters | Chief executive |
| Mai Fyfield | Non-executive director |
| Dharmash Mistry | Non-executive director |
| Matthew Ryder | Non-executive director |
The Premier League clubs vote also creates a wider liability. All 20 clubs will share the costs under the principle of collective responsibility. The BBC has reported that the costs could run into hundreds of millions of pounds. That raises a striking possibility. City, as a member club, could also end up paying part of the cost of legal action by its own sponsors.
Why the Sponsors Are Threatening to Sue
Etihad Airways have sponsored City since 2009. They also hold the naming rights for the club’s stadium. In a statement dated 30 September, the airline said the Premier League did not engage with them. They said the league gave them no chance to provide relevant information. The commission’s 40-page decision did not name Etihad, but the airline said it had created damaging implications for them. They said they were seeking legal advice to protect their interests.
Etisalat, the Abu Dhabi communications company, have gone further. In a statement, the company said: “Emirates Telecommunications Group Company PJSC (Etisalat) views the published findings of the English Premier League, as they relate to Etisalat, as entirely false and defamatory. Etisalat is actively considering all options relating to its rights and associated legal remedies in this matter.”
Both sponsors were at the centre of the commission’s findings, even though they were not parties to the case. The commission found that City had entered into sham contracts with commercial partners. It found that the club had artificially inflated its revenues by £830 million. The sponsors say the findings have damaged their names. They also want the league to answer for them in court.
Who Voted Against and Why
Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were the only two clubs to vote against the proposal. The Premier League clubs vote passed 18-2, but the two dissenters had very different reasons.
City’s opposition is easy to understand. The club are appealing the guilty verdict. They still maintain their innocence. They have also said the process was not impartial. From City’s point of view, the vote protects the people who brought the case against them.
Forest’s reasons, however, were different. Sources close to the club’s owner, Evangelos Marinakis, say the decision was not about solidarity with City. Their objection was procedural. They felt the league had given them too little information. They also felt they had too little time to consider it. Forest felt that such a decision warranted more scrutiny before any vote.
Forest have declined to comment officially. City’s chief financial officer, Ingo Bank, asked a pointed question at the meeting. He asked the league’s chair, Alison Brittain, if the sponsors’ threats had prompted the proposal. She said she could not comment.
What the Vote Means for Manchester City
The Premier League clubs vote changes the legal landscape around the case, but it does not change the football one. City are still appealing the verdict. They still maintain their innocence. The league has still not decided the sanction. What has changed is that the league’s directors can now face a lawsuit without risking their own money.
The commission’s findings were damning, and City are still appealing them. It found that City had broken more than 100 Premier League financial rules between 2009 and 2018. It found that the club had filed accounts that concealed the true state of its finances. It also found that City were significantly in breach of both the Premier League’s and UEFA’s spending limits. In addition, it found that City had failed to co-operate with the investigation. The commission upheld three of the four alleged breaches, but not the fourth.
City’s response was defiant. The club said the opinion had both disappointed and surprised them. They said a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all of their positions. They said they would be relentless, and where necessary proactive, in any and all appropriate regulatory and legal forums. They will now appeal on the basis that the opinion contains clear material errors of law, principle and fact.
Nobody knows when the league will decide the sanction. Football finance expert Stefan Borson told talkSPORT there is confusion over the stage the case has reached. He said somebody who should know had told him there had been no sanction hearing as of last week. He also said there was a question over whether the sanction hearing had been published or not. The uncertainty is part of the story.
Off the pitch, the verdict is already costing City. City Football Group lost a $2 billion loan from Apollo after the verdict came out. On the pitch, the team are third in the table on 22 points from 11 games. They are also winless in four league games, after defeats at Aston Villa, at home to Brighton and at Nottingham Forest, and a draw with Fulham. Fans booed Manchester City off after the 1-1 draw with Fulham at the Etihad last Saturday.
What Happens Next After the Premier League Clubs Vote
The next step is the appeal. City will argue that the commission’s opinion contains clear material errors. The league will defend it. The process could take months. The league will not decide the sanction until the appeal ends. The vote has not brought that day any closer.
The sponsors’ threat is the other live question. Etihad and Etisalat have said they are considering legal action, but neither has filed a case yet. If they do, the league’s directors will now have protection. The clubs will share the cost. That is what the vote decided, and it is why the vote mattered.
The Premier League clubs vote was a small step in a very long case. It did not punish City, and it did not clear them. It protected five people from the cost of a lawsuit nobody has filed yet. The big questions, the appeal and the sanction, are still to come. Until they are answered, the case will hang over the club, the league, and the season.
The vote also showed where the clubs stand. Eighteen of them backed the league’s board. Two did not. One of those two was City, and the other was Forest, for its own reasons. That split tells its own story. The league’s clubs are united behind their directors, and they are prepared to pay for it. Premier League football will watch what happens next. The next step could finally decide City’s fate.
